| Archives |
June, 2009
May, 2009
April, 2009
March, 2009
November, 2008
October, 2008
September, 2008
August, 2008
June, 2008
May, 2008
April, 2008
March, 2008
February, 2008
January, 2008
December, 2007
November, 2007
October, 2007
September, 2007
July, 2007
June, 2007
May, 2007
April, 2007
March, 2007
February, 2007
January, 2007
November, 2006
October, 2006
September, 2006
August, 2006
July, 2006
June, 2006
May, 2006
April, 2006
March, 2006
February, 2006
January, 2006
December, 2005
November, 2005
August, 2005
July, 2005
June, 2005
May, 2005
April, 2005
March, 2005
February, 2005
January, 2005
November, 2004
October, 2004
September, 2004
August, 2004
July, 2004
June, 2004
May, 2004
April, 2004
March, 2004
February, 2004
January, 2004
December, 2003
|
|
| Politics and Elections - February, 2008 |
|---|
| Thursday, February 28, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Maine
| | Maine and Nebraska have one thing in common that no other state can claim. These two states do not necessarily award all their electoral
votes to the candidate who gets the most votes statewide. Instead, they award one electoral vote for the winner of each congressional district (two in Maine,
three in Nebraska) and two to the statewide winner. Even with this unique electoral breakdown, all four of Maine's EVs will go to the Democratic nominee in
November. In case anyone's counting, The Blogging Caesar rates Maine as Strong DEM, Solid DEM, and Mod DEM for the statewide,
CD-1, and CD-2 races, respectively.
Unlike the presidential contest, the race for the Senate in Maine is strictly statewide. This year, Republican Susan Collins will try to win such a race
and hold on to the seat for the GOP. Collins is largely viewed as moderately to very vulnerable, though she outperformed prognostications to win in 2002 with
ease. In 2008, The Blogging Caesar sees a close but comfortable margin of victory for the incumbent, a Weak GOP Hold.
The Maine state page has a lot more information - and it's just a click away!
Next stop: Maryland
posted by Scott Elliott at 8:40pm 02/28/08 ::
link
|
|
| Tuesday, February 26, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Louisiana
| | The ravages of hurricane Katrina are still being felt in the Bayou State. The folks in Louisiana have yet to fully recover. One
of the side-effects of the storm has been a decreased Democratic presence in the state. Bobby Jindal's landslide victory in the 2007 gubernatorial election
here foreshadows the possibility of more GOP gains in the near future. Democratic Senator Mary Landrieu will have to run for all she's worth to keep her
seat in Washington, but even that may not be enough against a well-known party-switcher in State Treasurer John Kennedy. Score a
Weak GOP Gain in the only realistic pick-up opportunity for the GOP in the Senate this year. Count on Louisiana's nine
electoral votes going to the GOP candidate as well.
In the House, we won't see any change in the partisan makeup of Louisiana's delegation. We will see, however, a couple of new faces here pretty soon.
Special elections are being held May 3rd in district one to replace now-Governor Bobby Jindal and in district six in the wake of Republican Richard Baker's mid-term
resignation. A third new face will take a seat in Washington in November as a result of the retirement of Republican Jim McCrery in district four. None of
these seats - nor any of the other 4 - seems vulnerable at this point.
You can find lots more stuff on the Louisiana state page. Be sure to check it out.
Next stop: Maine
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:45pm 02/26/08 ::
link
|
| Monday, February 25, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Kentucky
| | Scandal brought down one of the few incumbents up for re-election in 2007, bluegrass GOP Governor Ernie Fletcher. His loss notwithstanding,
Kentucky has been and will continue to be reliably Republican in presidential races. Other offices, though, are not so fixed. Early on this cycle, it
appeared GOP Senator Mitch McConnell might be somewhat vulnerable. The Blogging Caesar doesn't think so. I don't see a McConnell defeat in the cards at
this point. In fact, I'm rating his re-election bid a Strong GOP Hold.
Turning to Kentucky's House delegation, John Yarmuth scored a Demcratic takeover in 2006, besting GOPer Anne Northup in district 3. After the loss, I
figured Yarmuth would succumb to a rematch with Northup if she decided to run. Fifteen months later, she has indeed thrown her hat in the ring, but her
prospects are surprisingly bleak. Perhaps a loss in last year's gubernatorial primary has tarnished her a bit. Whatever the reason, I have to give the
rematch - assuming Northup can with this primary - to Yarmuth.
Be sure to check out the Kentucky state page for more information.
Next stop: Louisiana
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:40pm 02/25/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Poll: Ralph Nader for president? Who does he hurt most?
| The latest edition of Election Projection's Weekly Poll is up. Ralph Nader's weekend announcement that he will run for the presidency
again this year begs for a poll here. I'll get back to the polls dealing with the candidates' ideology next week. In 2000, Nader's run probably handed
George W. Bush the victory. In 2004, he didn't have much of an impact. What about this year? Will his candidacy hurt one party's nominee more than
the other's, or will he be an insignificant sidenote? The poll is located in the right sidebar. Please be sure to cast your vote.
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:55am 02/25/08 ::
link
|
| Thursday, February 21, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Kansas
| | Other than Jim Leach's stunning loss in Iowa's 2nd district, the victory by Democrat Nancy Boyda in Kansas' 2nd distict might be the most
suprising upset of 2006. However, Republican Jim Ryun is back this year to try to wrest the seat back from the freshman congresswoman. Nine months out,
The Blogging Caesar thinks he has a great shot at doing just that. Call this one the first Weak GOP Gain in a long, long
time.
On the statewide front, Kansas has been a reliable, albeit smallish, source of electoral votes for the GOP in recent memory. In 2008, those six EVs will
remain in the GOP column once again by a wide margin. And finally, the Senate race - if you can call it that - should also be an easy win for the GOP.
Pat Roberts will earn a third term in the Senate without having to break a sweat.
The Kansas state page has all the details. Don't miss it!
Next stop: Kentucky
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:10pm 02/21/08 ::
link
|
| Wednesday, February 20, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Iowa
| | In 2000, Iowa went narrowly blue. In 2004, it went narrowly red. In 2008, it's anybody's guess which way it will turn. Since
2004 was a good night for Republicans overall and since 2008 might not be, The Blogging Caesar rates this state Weak DEM for
now.
In 2006, the GOP lost two House seats here and, with them, their delegate majority in the state. District 1 was no surprise, Jim Nussle left the seat in
this left-leaning district to run for governor. District 2 was a big surprise. David Loebsack came out of nowhere to shock GOP incumbent Jim Leach.
So unexpected was this outcome that the 2006 CNN election page did not even highlight this race as key. Now that it is in the hands of a Democrat, it will be
a difficult task for the GOP to take it back. It doesn't appear Leach will run aginst Loebsack, so this race, as well as the other 4 Iowa House seats will
remain in the incumbent party's hands.
In the Senate, powerful Demcratic Senator Tom Harkin will cruise to victory.
Be sure to check out the Iowa state page for more information.
Next stop: Kansas
posted by Scott Elliott at 10:25am 02/20/08 ::
link
|
| Monday, February 18, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Indiana
| | The Hoosier state saw an interesting turn of events during the last elections. Nowhere was the blue wave of 2006 larger than
here. Before Election Day, seven of the nine Indiana House seats were in GOP hands. Afterward, the Democrats held a 5-4 majority.
It was a stunning reversal in this usually reliably Republican state. Moreover, the three GOP candidates who lost were all incumbents. And while
all three seats are, as one might expect, vulnerable, The Blogging Caesar rates them as just possibly competitive, another indication of the difficult
road the GOP faces to get back on top. Of the three, I'd rate Hill vs. Sodrel III (or is it IV?) in CD-9 as the most likely to be hotly contested by
the time the election rolls around.
On the gubernatorial front, GOP incumbent Mitch Daniels, who rode a much redder environment to a takeover in 2004, is hoping to avoid the fate of his
now former congressional Republican colleagues. It will be a close race that he could lose. Nevertheless, it will open as a
Weak GOP Hold. The GOP will also hold onto the 11 votes in Indiana's electoral basket. Look for the GOP nominee to win here by yet
another comfortable margin.
The Indiana state page has all the details.
Next stop: Iowa
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:15pm 02/18/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Poll: Barack Obama's political ideology
| The latest edition of Election Projection's Weekly Poll is up. Over the next three weeks, we're going to be taking a look at this
audience's perceptions of the three possible nominees in terms of their political ideology. First up is Barack Obama. Do you think he is liberal,
moderate, or conservative, and to what degree? The poll is located in the right sidebar. Please be sure to cast your vote.
posted by Scott Elliott at 1:30pm 02/18/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Illinois
| | Illinois is a Strong DEM state when it comes to presidential politics. If native son Barack Obama wins
the Democratic nomination, it will undoubtedly move into solid territory. In the Senate race, Richard Durbin will also enjoy a Solid DEM
Hold.
Turning to the House, while I'm only tracking one race - Republican Jerry Weller's open seat in CD-11 (which I have rated a Weak DEM Gain
to start off), there are numerous possibly competitive races. On the GOP side, Mark Steven Kirk could face a stiff challenge from Daniel Seals in
CD-10, and two opens seats, Denny Hastert's seat in CD-14 and Ray Lahood's seat in CD-18, could also be close once the campaigns get into full swing. For the
Democrats, Melissa Bean's seat in CD-8 is the only somewhat vulnerable seat here.
Be sure to check out the Illinois state page for more detailed information.
Next stop: Indiana
posted by Scott Elliott at 11:50am 02/18/08 ::
link
|
| Saturday, February 16, 2008
|
|---|
| New RSS feed available
| I finally got around to installing RSS. Click on the option at the top of the right sidebar to subscribe to Election Projection's RSS
feed. Let me know if you have any trouble with it.
posted by Scott Elliott at 1:05pm 02/16/08 ::
link
|
| Friday, February 15, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Idaho
| | This state is normally deep red across all political categories. In 2008, this trend will be no different. However, there were
a couple of events here over the last two years that merit mention. First, in the blue wave election of 2006, Republican Bill Sali just barely - by Idaho's
standards - got by his Democratic challenger, Larry Grant, to retain the open seat in Idaho's first district for the GOP. Second, Senator Larry Craig's
bathroom indescretions made many a headline since then. At this point, neither seems to raise concern heading toward November.
With the benefit of incumbency and state partisanship now squarely on his side, Sali should easily win a re-match with Grant. And Larry Craig's decision
to resign paves the way for the GOP nominee - probably Lieutenant Governor Jim Risch - to enter the Senate following Craig's departure. The rating for that
seat will open as a Solid GOP Hold. The presidential race and the House races are pretty much the same.
More details available on the Idaho state page.
Next stop: Illinois
posted by Scott Elliott at 12:40pm 02/15/08 ::
link
|
| Wednesday, February 13, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Hawaii
| | The Aloha State is full of breathtaking excitement and wonder - but not when it comes to this year's political races. Besides
the presidential contest, only Hawaii's two House seats are up for grabs this year. Of course, even saying they are "up for grabs" is quite a stretch.
Both Democratic representatives will cruise to landslide wins.
Although Hawaii is a state where the legislature is made up of 64 Democrats and just 12 Republicans, there may be something positive developing for the GOP in
the future. In 2000, Al Gore walloped George W. Bush here by some 18 points. In 2004, John Kerry managed only a 9 point victory. That means 2008
should see a virtual tie, right? No, I don't think so. Governor Linda Lingle proved in 2002 and 2006 that a Republican can win here, but the prospects
of Hawaii going red in the presidential race any time soon are slim to none. Hawaii will remain a Strong DEM state at least
for the near future.
The Hawaii state page has the whole scoop.
Next stop: Idaho
posted by Scott Elliott at 11:20pm 02/13/08 ::
link
|
| Tuesday, February 12, 2008
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Georgia
| | The heart of the Solid South, Georgia was witness to one of the most surprising upsets of the 2002
election. Republican Sonny Perdue's out-of-nowhere victory over heavily-favored incumbent Governor Roy Barnes was
astounding. Massive GOP turnout in Georgia also saw the demise of Democratic Senator Max Cleland. His opponent,
Saxby Chambliss, is up for re-election this year.
Chambliss should have no problem keeping his seat, though another serious blue tide could make him uncomfortable. The
Blogging Caesar rates this race a Strong GOP Hold. And Georgia's electoral votes
should end up in the GOP's column by a similar margin.
In the House, we have a rematch brewing between incumbent Democrat Jim Marshall (CD-8) and Mac Collins.
After a wierd mid-decade round of redistricting, these two fought it out two years ago in a newly-formed district 8.
Marshall's victory by less than 1750 votes sets the stage for another close fight this year - if Collins can get by some
primary competition. Until signs point to an upset, The Blogging Caesar gives Marshall the nod once again.
Call it a Weak DEM Hold.
You'll find more details on the Georgia state page. Don't miss it!
Next stop: Hawaii
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:05pm 02/12/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Florida
| | Since the historic razor-close vote here in 2000 which propelled George W. Bush to the presidency,
Florida has moved slightly toward the red. In 2004, Bush carried the state by a close but not nerve-wracking 5
points. In 2002 and 2006, respectively, Jeb Bush and Charlie Crist easily won the statehouse. Only
Katherine Harris' self-aggrandizing run against Senator Bill Nelson in 2006 kept the GOP from sweeping all statewide
elections since 2002.
This year, the only statewide race is the battle for the White House. The overall political climate may give
Democrats reason to hope that the Florida prize which eluded them so narrowly in 2000 will be theirs in 2008.
For the time being, however, The Blogging Caesar sees Florida remaining a Weak GOP state.
Turning to House of Representatives, we see several new faces in Florida's delegation. No less than six
congresspersons will be seeking their first re-election victory. Two of them, Tim Mahoney (CD-16) and Ron Klein
(CD-22), both Democrats, will try to hold seats they won from the GOP last time around.
Of the two, Mahoney's seat appears to be the most vulnerable to turning red again. Republican Joe Negron, were
he to run, would make this seat a prime takeover target. (He narrowly lost to Mahoney in 2006 even though
disgraced Rep. Mark Foley's name was still on the ballot.) At this point, Negron has not jumped into the
race. Without him, Mahoney's seat starts out as a Weak DEM Hold. I'll leave
Klein's seat and Republican Vern Buchanan's seat in CD-13 in the possibly competitive category for now.
There is plenty more stuff on Florida's state page. Be sure to check it
out.
Next stop: Georgia
posted by Scott Elliott at 7:25pm 02/12/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Fifty-state tour: Delaware
| | Delaware is a reliably Democratic state which can be expected to vote blue at the top of the
ticket in all but the reddest of landslides. President Bush was able to cut the Democrat's margin of
victory from 13% in 2000 to just 7% in 2004, but I don't see the margin getting any closer than that in 2008.
This year, we are probably looking at a gap resembling the 2000 result. As such, Delaware will start out the year
as a Strong DEM state once again.
Down the ticket, we find the first gubernatorial race in our fifty-state tour. Democrat incumbent Ruth
Ann Minner is term-limited. In this mostly blue state, the open seat she leaves behind does not provide the GOP
with much of a pick-up opportunity. Call it a Strong DEM Hold.. In the Senate
race, Joe Biden's short-lived presidential campaign will not keep him from easily earning his 8th term in the Senate.
His will be a Solid DEM Hold.
Delaware has only one congressional district, and it has been filled by GOPer Mike Castle for over a decade. In
recent elections, he has handily won re-election, and I don't see any reason for that to change. So call this one a
Solid GOP Hold in this blue state.
Check out the Delaware state page for lots more information.
Next stop: Florida
posted by Scott Elliott at 10:15am 02/12/08 ::
link
|
| Monday, February 11, 2008
|
|---|
| Weekend primary/caucus results
| This weekend, five states conducted primaries or caucuses for one or both parties. On
Saturday, John McCain won a disputed race in the Washington GOP caucuses. Mike Huckabee benefited from an
apparent anti-McCain vote to blow out the senator in Kansas and eked out another victory in Louisiana. On the
Democratic side, Barack Obama registered a sweep over the weekend, taking Louisiana, Nebraska and Washington on
Saturday and Maine on Sunday. I'll be updating the primary table today to include these results.
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:50am 02/11/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Poll: President Bush's approval on Election Day
| The latest edition of Election Projection's Weekly Poll is up. Presidential approval plays
heavily in the outcome of elections when the incumbent is running. This year, George W. Bush is not running for
re-election. However, his approval numbers should still effect his party's chances somewhat. His approval
rating currently hovers in the lower 30's. What do you think it will be in November when folks head to the
polls? The poll is located in the right sidebar. Please be sure to cast your vote.
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:40am 02/11/08 ::
link
|
| Saturday, February 9, 2008
|
|---|
| Resuming the 50-state tour - Updated
| Some of you have written inquiring about the 50-state tour. With all the primary festivities
lately, I haven't had the opportunity to get past Connecticut. That will change next week. In fact, starting
Monday, I'll be posting preliminary evaluations of at least 2 states most days until they are all done. Here's a
tentative schedule of updates.
- Feb 11: Delaware, Florida, Georgia
- Feb 12: Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois
- Feb 13: Indiana, Iowa, Kansas
- Feb 14: Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine
- Feb 15: Maryland, Massachusetts
- Feb 16: Michigan, Minnesota
- Feb 17:
- Feb 18: Mississippi, Missouri, Montana
- Feb 19: Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire
- Feb 20: New Jersey, New Mexico
- Feb 21: New York
- Feb 22: North Carolina, North Dakota
- Feb 23: Ohio Oklahoma
- Feb 24:
- Feb 25: Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island
- Feb 26: South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee
- Feb 27: Texas, Utah
- Feb 28: Vermont, Virginia, Washington
- Feb 29: West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming
This is an agressive schedule, but I'll try my best to keep to it. Also, I plan to finish updating the primary
table sometime today with the results from Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday.
Update: The primary table has been updated.
posted by Scott Elliott at 11:10am 02/09/08 ::
link
|
| Thursday, February 7, 2008
|
|---|
| Oh my! Romney's out - Updated
| | After John McCain's strong showing on Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday and facing a split base of
supporters with Mike Huckabee, Mitt Romney has dropped out
of the GOP race. Some may have seen this coming, but I figured he'd be in it to the end. I'll be very
interested to see if we receive similar news from the Huckabee campaign in the coming days. A Huckabee departure
soon after Romney has bowed out would seem to confirm the charge that he stayed in solely to hurt Romney's chances against
McCain. Stay tuned.
Update: Kim Priestap over at Wizbang! has been
all over Romney's decision.
At the time of this update, she's up to Update X. Bob Owens, referenced in Update VII,
gets it right.
posted by Scott Elliott at 1:10pm 02/07/08 ::
link
|
| Wednesday, February 6, 2008
|
|---|
| Blogtalk radio show
| Last night, I was a guest on Political Vindication's blogtalk radio show. For nearly an
hour, Shane, Frank, and I chatted about Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday, the House and Senate races, and a lot of other
stuff. It was a blast. If you missed it, you can catch it anytime. Just follow
this link.
The show will start automatically, and I come on right at the 69-minute mark.
posted by Scott Elliott at 3:10pm 02/06/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday reactions
| | The biggest day of the primary season has passed. Lots went on yesterday and into the wee
hours of this morning as the nation watched the numbers come in from all over. I was mesmerized by the constantly
changing and expanding parade of returns on my television screen. Last night reminded me why I love the competition
of politics so much. Today, as the dust still settles, let me give you my initial reactions to what transpired.
1. Mike Huckabee shined in the south. The former Southern governor's performance surprised me.
I figured Huck was done after losses in South Carolina and Florida. Up until curtain, the polls from states such
as Alabama, Georgia and Tennessee seemed to bear that out. However, a late round of polls from Insider Advantage,
which were released after I made my predictions, showed the last-minute numbers breaking in Huckabee's favor.
2. California was huge. The Golden State has the largest population, yes, but I'm not stating the
obvious here. It was the margin of victory by Hillary Clinton and John McCain that will make
California's results last night pivotal in both nomination races. As the day dawned yesterday, much of the
discussion centered around who would win California. Both Clinton and Barack Obama and McCain and Mitt Romney were
deadlocked there in the polls.
The earlier results heightened the anticipation. With McCain winning the big block states in the Northeast,
folks were wondering if Romney might win California and head off a rout. On the Democratic side, with Barack
Obama amassing several impressive wins east of the Mississippi, a win in California would give Obama claim to a
decisive victory on Super Tuesday.
However, the outcomes differed on both accounts. Instead of Romney gaining traction in the face of McCain's big
night, he - and any remaining chance he had at the nomination - was blown away in California. McCain's 10-point
victory sealed the deal for him. He will be the GOP nominee for president. For Obama, the potential
to wake up as frontrunner this morning vanished instantly when California was called for Hillary with less than 20% of
the vote counted. Her 10-point victory was a resounding confirmation that she is indeed still the one to beat.
3. Huckabee's impact on Romney. One common theme during the days before yesterday was the effect that
Huckabee would have on Romney's chance at the nomination. Looking at the numbers from last night, Romney was
hurt by the fact that Huckabee was still in the running. However, the degree to which that was the case is
debatable.
I've done a quick study on how the results would have changed if Huck had dropped out after Florida.
As expected, the larger a proportion of Huck's vote I give to Romney in my analysis, the closer Romney's delegate count gets
to McCain's. But even with Romney getting 2 out of 3 Huckabee votes, he still does not surpass McCain on the
scoreboard yesterday - and that's not including the advantage McCain had already heading into the day.
Bottom line: Huck did impact Romney, but McCain would still be the frontrunner even with Huckabee out of the race.
4. Democratic turnout was very impressive. Voters had turned out in far larger numbers on the Democratic
side in the primaries and caucuses before yesterday. That trend continued. Missouri is a great example.
Approximately 820,000 people voted in the Democratic primary. On the GOP side, the number was less than 600,000.
The story was the same in practically every primary held yesterday. Even in a strong red states like Georgia and
Tennessee, Democratic primary voters outnumbered their GOP counterparts by 75,000 or so.
I'm not sure what to make of these turnout results. The initial reaction would be one of anxiety looking ahead
to November. Certainly, if the general election reflects the same kind of participation, it is hard to see a
happy ending for the GOP. That said, we've still got a long way to go until November, and the Democrats now face
the challenge of keeping up the intensity over a sustained period of time. That's not an easy task. Could they
be peaking at the wrong time? We'll have to wait and see.
5. A brokered convention likely for the Democrats - only. Both Hillary and Obama can make the claim that they had
a good showing last night. That fact indicates the tightness of their race and the increasing likelihood that
neither will secure nomination before the convention in August. Adding to that probability are the super delegates,
which make up a substantial portion of the total delegate pool. They will be by and large uncommitted before the
convention. With the committed delegate counts so close, it is difficult to see how one or the other can get to
the needed majority before the primaries end.
On the other hand, McCain's big night has solidified the chance that we will know the GOP nominee well before the
convention in September. I was wavering a bit on my third edict after
Huckabee won some states I had predicted for McCain, but the result in California put my hesitation to bed - just in
time for me to get there myself.
Whew! What a night! It reminded me - as if that were necessary - why I love the competition of politics
so much. This election season has been filled with excitement and drama, ups and downs, changing frontrunners and
disappointing dropouts. What more could we ask for? And to think, we haven't even settled on the party
nominees yet!
posted by Scott Elliott at 12:20pm 02/06/08 ::
link
|
| Tuesday, February 5, 2008
|
|---|
Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday predictions and results - Updated
| | Update: This evening at 10:15-10:55 EST, I will be a guest on Political
Vindication's blogtalk radio show. Frank, Shane and I will be discussing today's happenings as well as looking
into several House and Senate races on tap this year. You can tune in live to the show at
Political Vindication Radio.
We have arrived at the biggest day in the history of primaries. Almost half of these
United States are conducting their primaries or caucuses today. Over 1000 delegates are at stake on the Republican
side and twice that are being contested on the Democratic side. Truly this is the big one.
Here's how I see the Republican races unfolding today. John McCain will be the big winner. He is still
riding the momentum from his victories in South Carolina and Florida - plus he enjoys a structural advantage.
Unlike the Democrats, who award all delegates (except super delegates) proportionally according to the vote, state GOP
conventions have several methods for allocating their delegates. Many states have a winner-take-all format.
Others use a proportional model. Still others choose a modified winner-take-all system which takes congressional
district results into account.
It just so happens that in many states where McCain is ahead, the method is winner-take-all. As a result, he
stands to gain large delegate blocks in such states as New York, Arizona, Missouri, and New Jersey. On the other
hand, with the exception of Utah, states Mitt Romney might be expected to win break down the allocation of delegates to
more than one candidate. For example, Romney's home state of Massachusetts employs a proportional model.
The bottom line is that McCain's delegates will come easier than Romney's, increasing the effect of his strong
polling numbers nationwide. I'm predicting McCain will win 60% to 65% of the delegates at stake today. Mitt
Romney will come in with 25% to 30% or so, and Mike Huckabee, around 10%. Ron Paul's best chance of picking up
delegates will come in Alaska. Other than that, he may snatch a delegate here and there, but his haul won't amount
to much.
On the Democratic side, the fact that every state awards proportionally will make it difficult for either Obama or
Hillary to gain an overwhelming delegate advantage. In fact, I don't see either candidate earning more than 55%
of the delegates to be awarded today. Looking at the polling data, I would say Obama will get 25 to 75 more
delegates than Hillary. Last month, conventional wisdom pointed to a Republican brokered convention.
After today, ironically, it may be the Democrats who will be more likely facing a convention fight.
Here is a roundup of other blogger predictions, followed by two tables containing mine.
If you have posted predictions, send me an email so I can put you on this list.
The Blogging Caesar's Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday Predictions
See explanations of the different methods for allocating delegates at the bottom of this post. "TBC" stands
for "The Blogging Caesar" and represents my predictions. The actual results will be filled in under the columns
labeled "Actual" (no, really!).
| Republicans |
|
Winner |
Runner-up |
Margin |
|
|
| State |
TBC |
Actual |
TBC |
Actual |
TBC |
Actual |
Del |
Allocation |
| Alabama |
JM |
MH |
MH |
JM |
6% |
4% |
48 |
WTAD/PS [8] |
| Alaska |
JM |
MR |
RP |
MH |
6% |
22% |
29 |
Dist/St [3] |
| Arizona |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
16% |
14% |
53 |
WTA [1] |
| Arkansas |
MH |
MH |
JM |
JM |
21% |
40% |
34 |
WTA [1] |
| California |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
2% |
8% |
173 |
WTA,DS [2] |
| Colorado |
MR |
MR |
JM |
JM |
5% |
41% |
46 |
Dist/St [3] |
| Connecticut |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
12% |
19% |
30 |
WTA [1] |
| Delaware |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
6% |
12% |
19 |
WTA [1] |
| Georgia |
JM |
MH |
MR |
JM |
3% |
2% |
72 |
WTA,DS [2] |
| Illinois |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
5% |
18% |
70 |
DE,US [4] |
| Massachusetts |
MR |
MR |
JM |
JM |
19% |
10% |
43 |
Prop [5] |
| Minnesota |
JM |
MR |
MR |
JM |
8% |
20% |
41 |
Dist/St [3] |
| Missouri |
JM |
JM |
MH |
MH |
6% |
1% |
58 |
WTA [1] |
| Montana |
JM |
MR |
MR |
RP |
3% |
13% |
25 |
WTA [1] |
| New Jersey |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
18% |
27% |
52 |
WTA [1] |
| New York |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MR |
26% |
23% |
101 |
WTA [1] |
| North Dakota |
JM |
MR |
MR |
JM |
10% |
13% |
26 |
Prop [5] |
| Oklahoma |
JM |
JM |
MR |
MH |
6% |
4% |
41 |
WTA,DS [2] |
| Tennessee |
JM |
MH |
MH |
JM |
6% |
2% |
55 |
PW50,DS [6] |
| Utah |
MR |
MR |
JM |
JM |
23% |
85% |
36 |
WTA [1] |
| West Virginia |
JM |
MH |
MR |
MR |
14% |
5% |
30 |
WTA,MB [7] |
|
| Democrats |
|
Winner |
Runner-up |
Margin |
|
|
| State |
TBC |
Actual |
TBC |
Actual |
TBC |
Actual |
Del |
Allocation |
| Alabama |
BO |
BO |
HC |
HC |
6% |
14% |
60 |
Prop [5] |
| Alaska |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
9% |
50% |
18 |
Prop [5] |
| Arizona |
HC |
HC |
BO |
BO |
4% |
9% |
67 |
Prop [5] |
| Arkansas |
HC |
HC |
BO |
BO |
6% |
42% |
47 |
Prop [5] |
| California |
BO |
HC |
HC |
BO |
1% |
10% |
441 |
Prop [5] |
| Colorado |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
2% |
35% |
71 |
Prop [5] |
| Connecticut |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
2% |
4% |
60 |
Prop [5] |
| Delaware |
BO |
BO |
HC |
HC |
11% |
10% |
23 |
Prop [5] |
| Georgia |
BO |
BO |
HC |
HC |
21% |
36% |
103 |
Prop [5] |
| Idaho |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
7% |
62% |
23 |
Prop [5] |
| Illinois |
BO |
BO |
HC |
HC |
29% |
32% |
185 |
Prop [5] |
| Kansas |
BO |
BO |
HC |
HC |
7% |
48% |
41 |
Prop [5] |
| Massachusetts |
HC |
HC |
BO |
BO |
4% |
15% |
121 |
Prop [5] |
| Minnesota |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
2% |
35% |
88 |
Prop [5] |
| Missouri |
BO |
BO |
HC |
HC |
9% |
1% |
88 |
Prop [5] |
| New Jersey |
HC |
HC |
BO |
BO |
5% |
10% |
107 |
Prop [5] |
| New Mexico |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
8% |
1% |
38 |
Prop [5] |
| New York |
HC |
HC |
BO |
BO |
13% |
17% |
281 |
Prop [5] |
| North Dakota |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
5% |
24% |
21 |
Prop [5] |
| Oklahoma |
BO |
HC |
HC |
HC |
9% |
24% |
47 |
Prop [5] |
| Tennessee |
HC |
HC |
BO |
BO |
11% |
13% |
85 |
Prop [5] |
| Utah |
HC |
BO |
BO |
HC |
2% |
18% |
29 |
Prop [5] |
|
NOTES
- WTA - Winner take all, statewide. The candidate who gets the most votes statewide wins all the
delegates at stake.
- WTA,DS - Winner take all, district and statewide. The candidate who gets the most votes in each
congressional district wins all the delegates allocated to that district (usually 3). The candidate who gets the
most votes statewide wins the rest of the delegates (can vary greatly from state to state).
- Dist/St - District and state conventions. Each district will hold a primary election in which voters
can vote for qualified candidates or as "unpledged" (undecided). Delegates are awared according to district results.
- DE,US - District delegate election, unpledged state delegates. District delegates are awared according
to district voting, while the rest of the state's delegates remain officially unpledged until the convention.
- Prop - Proportional, statewide. Each candidate will receive the number of delegates proportional to
the votes received. For example, a candidate who gets 45% of the vote gets 45% of the delegates at stake.
In Democratic races, most states award some of their delegates proportionally according to district vote in addition to
the delegates awarded on a statewide basis.
- PW50,DS - Proportional under 50%, winner take all plus 50%, distict and statewide. If no candidate
gets a majority of the votes, the delegates will be split proportionally. If a candidate does get more than 50%,
that candidate will earn all delegates. This test is done on a district-wide basis for district delegates and on a
statewide basis for other delegates.
- WTA,MB - Winner take all, multi-ballot. District delegates (9) will be awarded on May 13. Other
delegates will be awarded by winner-take-all balloting at the convention held today. Multiple rounds of voting will
be conducted if necessary.
- WTAD/PS - Modified winner-take-all, district. Proportional, statewide. Delegates allocated by district
are winner-take-all if winning candidate has more than 50% of the vote in the district or if only one candidate receives
more than 15%. If neither of these conditions is met, the top vote-getter is awarded 2 delegates and the runner-up
is awarded 1. Bonus delegates are allocated proportionally based on the statewide vote.
|
posted by Scott Elliott at 12:05am 02/05/08 ::
link
|
| Monday, February 4, 2008
|
|---|
| Poll: Are you glad the Patriots lost the Super Bowl?
| The latest edition of Election Projection's Weekly Poll is up. This week I thought we'd
deviate from politics a bit. Last night, the New York Giants defeated the previously unbeaten New England
Patriots who were seeking an historic undefeated championship season. No team has gone undefeated since the NFL
season was expanded to 16 games. The Patriots are the only team to get to the Super Bowl with that chance.
Are you glad they didn't make it? Or were you rooting for a perfect season? The poll is located in
the right sidebar. Please be sure to cast your vote.
posted by Scott Elliott at 10:00am 02/04/08 ::
link
|
| Saturday, February 2, 2008
|
|---|
| Edict #3: John McCain will attain the delegates needed for the GOP nomination in March
| | By edict of The Blogging Caesar, it is hereby decreed that Arizona Senator John McCain will
be the 2008 GOP nominee for President of the United States. He will accumulate 1,191 delegates - the number of
delegates needed to secure the nomination - sometime during the primaries held in the month of March.
I hereby seal and deliver this edict today, Saturday, the 2nd of February, in the year of our Lord 2008.
posted by Scott Elliott at 9:50pm 02/02/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Super Tuesday predictions coming
| I'm going to be posting a table sometime before Tuesday afternoon with my predictions for
Super-Duper-Mega-Jumbo Tuesday. Yes, I will be prognosticating all 21 states. In the meantime, send me your
link if you'll be posting predictions, too.
posted by Scott Elliott at 10:30am 02/02/08 ::
link
|
|
|---|
| Super Tuesday polls
| C.H. Truth has posted a
nice summary of GOP polls from Super Tuesday states. Scroll down for
Democratic polls.
posted by Scott Elliott at 10:30am 02/02/08 ::
link
|
| Friday, February 1, 2008
|
|---|
| An edict upcoming after all
| I'm unable to resist. So, even though I felt earlier that I could not issue an edict on the
GOP race, I've since changed my mind. Stay tuned; The Blogging Caesar will issue edict #3 tomorrow.
posted by Scott Elliott at 2:10pm 02/01/08 ::
link
|
| |
|
|